Reviewer Guidelines
Standards and expectations for JOS peer reviewers.
Guardians of Scientific Quality
Reviewers are essential to maintaining JOS's reputation for rigorous ophthalmic research publishing.
Core Responsibilities
- Evaluate manuscripts objectively for scientific validity and clinical merit
- Complete reviews within 14-21 days
- Declare any conflicts of interest before accepting
- Maintain strict confidentiality of manuscript contents
- Provide constructive, specific, and respectful feedback
Review Criteria
When evaluating an ophthalmic manuscript, consider:
- Originality and significance of the clinical question
- Appropriateness of study design and methodology
- Quality of clinical images and data presentation
- Clarity and logical flow of presentation
- Clinical applicability and patient care implications
Ethical Conduct
Reviewers must adhere to COPE guidelines. Do not use ideas or data from manuscripts under review for personal benefit.
