Reviewer Resources
Tools and guidelines supporting Energy Conservation reviewers in evaluating sustainability research submissions effectively.
Review Support Center
Resources to help reviewers provide thorough, constructive evaluations of energy efficiency and conservation research manuscripts.
Our evaluation framework helps reviewers provide consistent, high-quality assessments addressing key aspects of energy research manuscripts.
Evaluation Criteria
Structured criteria covering scientific validity, methodology, technical accuracy, and presentation quality for sustainability research.
Report Templates
Standardized formats ensuring comprehensive feedback addressing all essential aspects of energy conservation manuscripts.
Ethics Guidance
Guidelines for identifying ethical concerns, conflicts of interest, and research integrity issues in sustainability studies.
Reviewers should verify compliance with appropriate reporting guidelines for energy research and engineering studies.
- CONSORT for randomized trials evaluating energy interventions and efficiency technologies
- PRISMA for systematic reviews and meta-analyses of conservation literature
- STROBE for observational studies of energy consumption patterns and policy impacts
- Technical reporting standards for engineering methodology and data presentation
Quality reviews: Focus on constructive feedback that helps authors improve their energy conservation research. Avoid purely critical comments without actionable suggestions for sustainability manuscripts.
Effective reviews balance thoroughness with efficiency. Focus on substantive scientific issues while noting presentation concerns. Prioritize feedback on methodology, technical validity, and environmental implications over minor stylistic matters for energy manuscripts.
Our ManuscriptZone system provides dedicated reviewer interface for accessing assigned manuscripts, submitting reports, and tracking review history for energy research. Contact [email protected] for assistance with technical issues or questions about conservation manuscript review.
Access Reviewer Portal
Log in to manage your energy review assignments and access resources.
Reviewer Login
